Photo credit Mihaela Bodlovic

The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie

The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie
3

The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie, written by Edinburgh-born author Muriel Spark, tells the story of a teacher in a girls’ school who takes a small group of pupils under her wing, introducing them to interesting subjects like art history and fascism rather than the staid curriculum. However, Miss Brodie has a dark side. Is she a genuinely inspirational teacher or a bully who demands loyalty instead of earning it? Do her girls succeed later in life despite or because of her? Miss Brodie remains as fascinating and complex a character now as when Spark first wrote her over 60 years ago.

A little over 20 years after first being adapted for the Lyceum’s stage, writer David Harrower and director Vicky Featherstone bring a new version of the novel to Edinburgh with National Theatre Scotland. It is something of a curate’s egg of a production, with a fine central performance from Gayle Rankin as Miss Brodie let down by some frustrating decisions.

Most notable of these is the set. The stage is filled with a pink-carpeted amphitheatre designed to evoke the Coliseum in Miss Brodie’s beloved Rome. This leaves little space for the actors to perform as they clamber up and down the amphitheatre’s steep steps, or totter around its narrow platforms. Actors departing the stage to the rear are startlingly visible as heads bobbing about above the uppermost step, while the acting is sometimes hindered by the effort and concentration clearly required to negotiate the set.

Presumably the idea was to inject some dynamism into what risks being a static production (with most scenes taking place in classrooms), but the contrivance merely distracts the audience from the world of the play. Coupled with microphones frustratingly fading in and out for some actors and a momentum-sapping over-long runtime, the result is a production that remains stubbornly unabsorbing.

This is a shame, as there is much to like about the play. Gayle Rankin makes for a largely compelling Miss Brodie, stalking the stage in flowing, brightly patterned clothes, an anachronistic symbol of her allure among the staid 1930s fashions of her fellow teachers. Rankin dominates her class of girls with sweeping gestures and widespread arms – gestures that are nicely mimicked by her pupils –  while bringing a sly sensuality to her interactions with the besotted male teachers.

Rankin’s best scenes come with Bobby Rainsbury as favourite pupil Sandy. The two share an intense chemistry, as Sandy first falls under Miss Brodie’s spell and then comes to desire her downfall. Rainsbury brings a persuasively earnest childishness to 12-year-old Sandy at the start of the play, before delivering composure and poise as the older version of the character. The cast overall is strong.

David Harrower’s adaptation captures the sharpness of Spark’s original writing, while there are also some nice moments of staging. The use of projection to conjure the ominous appearance of a crowd of Italian fascists is unsettling. Miss Brodie’s final downfall, as she is shamefully stripped by the girls who were her proteges, is powerful, engendering sympathy for an often unsympathetic character.

Gayle Rankin captures the complexity and contradictions of Miss Brodie beautifully, from her domineering beginnings to her wheedling, deluded end. She is backed up by a talented young cast and a sharply written script. It is a pity the production’s length and missteps with the set make for a play that cannot fully deliver on its potential.

 

Performed at The Royal Lyceum Theatre, Edinburgh
Runs until Sunday 18 October 2026: see website for times
Running time: 3 hours including interval
Adapted by David Harrower from the novel by Muriel Spark
Directed by Vicky Featherstone
Set Designer: Chloe Lamford
Lighting Designer: Lizzie Powell
Costume Designer: Anna Orton
Sound Designer: Pippa Murphy
Video Designer: Lewis Den Hertog
Cast: Maureen Beattie, Liberty Black, Dyfan Dwyfor, Brian Ferguson, Sophie Fortune, Tallulah Greive, Shreya Khaund Marshall, Bobby Rainsbury, Gayle Rankin