Angel’s Bone

3

This opera is a decade old now, and after success in America comes to London with ENO after a recent outing in Manchester. Composer Du Yun and librettist Royce Vavrek take on the issue of modern slavery, but from an unconventional angle, in a work that lasts just shy of ninety minutes. This is a difficult and important subject, but one that is made more difficult and ultimately unrewarding by its handling. While there is undoubted technical skill at work, most notably in the resilient performances of the singers and the technicians, ultimately the opera itself seemed much less than the sum of its parts.

We find ourselves in a suburban setting – it could be a performance of Trouble in Tahiti – as a husband and wife squabble over the disappointments of their middle class life. But then two dishevelled, muddied angels land in their garden (we never get to know how or why), and they are presented with temptation. All too quickly, they decide to make use of them instead, brutally pruning their wings to prevent escape, making use of their feathers for gain, and opening the two helpless creatures up to sexual and physical abuse by their neighbours. There is no moralising denouement, evil is not punished, and one enormity is piled on another, as the wife channels her experiences into a crafty venture into celebrity culture andd pseudo-victimhood, after the husband comes to grief.

Musically the most interesting sections are at the beginning and end and in the solo opportunities afforded to the two angels – two really fine performances under pressure from Matthew McKinney and Mariam Wallentin, together with a quietly mournful angelic observer’s perspective from Keith Pun. The husband and wife, Mr and Mrs X.E., are sung with admirable skill and energy by Rodney Earle Clarke and Allison Cook. But the music is clangorous, relentless and ultimately tedious, as is the protracted party/orgy depicted across the central span of the piece. The composer is quoted in the programme as saying, ‘I think first about human reactions, rather than what musical style would serve the language. I’m not afraid of any style because for me, they are all tools.’ Perhaps she should have thought more carefully about the fit of musical style to the events described and moods depicted. There are also elements of pretension in the libretto, particularly in its handling of religious themes, that do not help achieve credibility or empathy.

Marg Horwell’s set is very clever, perhaps too clever in fact. As the opera begins, the four corners of the house open out and revolve, a device that serves to give us multiple aspects and viewpoints on the action. This is excellently done, but it is coupled with three close-up video cameramen continuously shadowing the characters, whose shots are then projected above the set to give close-up detail of the characters and their expressions. This is absorbing for a while, but ultimately becomes distracting as your gaze flits uneasily from the singers and the set to the projected sequences above, and back again. There are surely other and better ways of immersing us and implicating us in what is happening in front of us.

I should add, in fairness, that the mainly young audience on press night had a much more positive view of the evening than I did: it was vigorously applauded at the end, while I felt a measure of relief. It is clear from the essays in the the programme that the creative team had sought complexity both in their handling of the issues and in their portrayal of the characters, but this did not communicate itself to me across either words or music.

Coliseum

Composer: Du Yun

Librettist: Royce Vavrek

Director: Kip Williams

Conductor: Baldur Brönniman

Cast includes: Allison Cook, Rodney Earl Clarke, Matthew McKinney, Keith Pun, Mariam Wallentin

1 hr 15 mins, no interval

Until 31 October 2026

Photo Credit: Nirah Sanghani